Sainsbury’s lines up top quartet for possible pitch

Sainsbury’s is reviewing its £60m creative account and it seems that Mother, MullenLowe and Wieden+Kennedy are lining up against AMV BBDO, which has held the account since since 1981 with the exception of a brief interregnum at M&C Saatchi. But it isn’t a formal pitch, according to Campaign, although the AAR is involved. Maybe some of you understand these things..

As lists go it seems sensible enough. All the agencies know retail: Mother handles Boots, MullenLowe handled Morrisons before it went to Publicis, Wieden+Kennedy had a bash at Tesco and now handles TK Maxx. At one point Sainsbury’s is believed to have talked to newbies Lucky Generals and Joint. CHI/The&Partnership might have been expected to be a contender but it’s going for Marks & Spencer instead, in a ‘closed’ WPP pitch. CHI handles Argos which Sainsbury’s is in the process of buying.

mog_3517105bWhile agencies in France and Germany seem to produce brilliant retail ads out of a hat British agencies find this far more difficult, apart from some of their all-singing and dancing Christmas efforts (like Sainsbury’s Mog, left). Which probably says something about retailers, particularly supermarkets, as clients. They’re obsessed with price (the more so in the post-Aldi and Lidl era) and short-term promotions. Which doesn’t leave much left over for proper ads through the year. Waitrose may prove to be the exception at adam&eveDDB.

On the face of it it’s hard to see how an agency, in these circumstances, could have done a much better job than AMV. How will Sainsbury’s work out if one of these contenders can do it better? That’s hard to see as well unless they produce a full-on campaign for the pitch – assuming Sainsbury’s has one, of course.

Could be an expensive business for somebody.


Lucky Generals tell me they weren’t involved. Why not?

You May Also Like

About Stephen Foster

Stephen is a former editor of Marketing Week and London Evening Standard advertising columnist. He wrote City Republic for Brand Republic and is a partner in communications consultancy The Editorial Partnership.