At virtually the same moment trendy digital agency Dare triumphantly announced it had won the £28m Gocompare.com price comparison account, it also had to make an embarrassing disclosure.
It had just lost Danny Brooke-Taylor (pictured), the executive creative director who, probably more than anyone else at the agency, had laid the groundwork for this signature – and possibly breakthrough – business win.
Tempting though it would be to dismiss Brooke-Taylor’s so far unexplained departure as an ironic footnote to a much bigger event, it is much more significant than that.
The fact is Brooke-Taylor is, or was, almost the last man standing from one half of what – only 18 months ago – was hailed as an historic agency merger.
That of Miles Calcraft Briginshaw Duffy – the traditional, craft-based agency incarnate – with Dare – now into its tenth birthday, BBH-bred, and one of the most respected digital agencies on the London scene.
MCBD was lauded for its branding skills, its professionalism and its blue chip client list. But was viewed, in the nicest possible way, as a little out of its time in the agency world, with a bias towards print advertising. Worse, it never seemed to make quite enough money. Dare, on the other hand, was cutting edge and dynamic, respected for its management skills, but apparently incapable of producing standout creative work – a criticism frequently, and with some justice, levelled at digital agencies.
By this time, both agencies were owned by marketing services aggregator Cossette. Cossette in Europe was itself undergoing a rebrand (as EdC, or Esprit de Corps), one of whose principal features was the promotion of Dare founder Mark Collier to EdC group chairman. No doubt hoping to make a virtue out of financial necessity, Collier and his colleagues saw lots of ‘synergy’ (and who’s to say they were wrong at the time?) in bringing the two agency brands together.
The resultant merger of Dare and MCBD left little doubt as to who was on top – the MCBD name disappeared, as well it might given MCBD had a staff of 77 at the time and Dare one of 189. But that numerical supremacy was not reflected in the senior management line-up. Helen Calcraft, the ‘C’ in MCBD, was the new executive chairman; Andy Nairn, the executive planning officer at MCBD, was chief planning officer; Danny Brooke-Taylor, ex-TBWA, and MCBD ecd since 2007, joined forces with Dare founder Flo Heiss as joint executive creative director; and Michael Pring, MCBD managing director, became managing partner at Dare.
Only Nairn is left. Calcraft scaled back her commitments to a part-time role late last year; Pring quit last October. Now Brooke-Taylor (l) has left in equally mysterious circumstances.
I know what experienced agency hands are going to say. Mergers were ever thus. They are a polite fiction – designed to keep the clients in ignorance – for a Darwinian dogfight in which the weaker parties eventually take their money and run, or get run over.
Except, if that was the cynical calculus behind this particular merger, it has badly misfired. Too many top MCBD people have quit too quickly for client comfort.
To explain what I mean, let’s return to that £28m Gocompare account. The foundation of that win was surely the £17m moneysupermarket.com price comparison business, wrested by MCBD from Doner Cardwell Hawkins – and stiff competition from Fallon, Adam & Eve and BBH – in 2009, when Brooke-Taylor was MCBD ecd.
Not everyone was a fan of the work – fronted by comedian Omid Djajili – that followed (I was, especially the valedictory execution featuring Prezza and his two Jags). Arguably, MCBD – however entertaining it made the ads – failed to come up with a memorable enough brand-name mnemonic, and paid for it with the loss of the account early last year.
But it would be difficult to deny the agency succeeded in one crucial task where internet companies (and especially price comparison aggregators) often fail. It gave moneysupermarket.com a distinctive personality, backed by a compelling and entertaining narrative.
It is these skills that I suspect will be lost with the extinction of the MCBD culture, even though the abiding brand asset of Gio Compario should – in theory – make Dare’s task that much easier a second time around.